{"figure":"hold-windows","title":"Every guarded failure, from detection to the end of its guard's hold window","page":"https://www.orbytlabs.ai/research/recursive-self-improvement","url":"https://www.orbytlabs.ai/research/recursive-self-improvement/hold-windows.json","source":"rsi-figures.generated.json, written by scripts/research/method-figures/recursive-self-improvement.ts from docs/org/improvements/rsi.json, the judge's daily record","caveats":["A hold is the judge's rule, applied to its own records: a guard holds when no failure citing its lesson is detected within 28 days of the guard landing. A failure nobody recorded cannot break a hold, and neither can a recurrence written only as a note on the old lesson.","Each row is a numbered lesson whose incident trailer the judge could read. Lessons written before the trailer became required are not in the record.","Rows run in the order the failures were detected, so a lesson's number can come before an earlier one's.","Detection and guard days are calendar days in UTC, so a guard landed the same day reads as zero days to guard."],"not_shown":["Incidents with no landed guard, which have no window to draw, and lessons before the incident trailer was required."],"counted_on":"2026-11-19T19:15:55Z","cite_as":"Orbyt Labs, Every guarded failure, from detection to the end of its guard's hold window (2026-11-19), https://www.orbytlabs.ai/research/recursive-self-improvement/hold-windows.json","hold_days":"28","record_ends":"2026-11-19","short_window_from":"2026-10-23","columns":[{"key":"lesson","label":"The lesson's number in docs/lessons-learned.md"},{"key":"detected","label":"UTC day the failure was detected"},{"key":"guard_landed","label":"UTC day the guard for it landed"},{"key":"days_to_guard","label":"Days from detection to the guard","unit":"days"},{"key":"hold_state","label":"held, broken, or pending (the window has not completed)"},{"key":"window_completes","label":"UTC day the hold window completes"},{"key":"window_stopped","label":"UTC day the drawn window stops: its end, the recurrence's detection, or the record's end"},{"key":"broken_by_lesson","label":"The lesson whose recurrence broke the hold; empty otherwise"},{"key":"caught_by","label":"Who the judge's record says caught the failure: machine, person, or unattributed (found in production, no catcher recorded)"}],"rows":[{"lesson":73,"detected":"2026-09-12","guard_landed":"2026-09-12","days_to_guard":0,"hold_state":"held","window_completes":"2026-10-10","window_stopped":"2026-10-10","broken_by_lesson":null,"caught_by":"unattributed"},{"lesson":75,"detected":"2026-09-12","guard_landed":"2026-09-14","days_to_guard":2,"hold_state":"held","window_completes":"2026-10-12","window_stopped":"2026-10-12","broken_by_lesson":null,"caught_by":"person"},{"lesson":74,"detected":"2026-09-13","guard_landed":"2026-09-13","days_to_guard":0,"hold_state":"held","window_completes":"2026-10-11","window_stopped":"2026-10-11","broken_by_lesson":null,"caught_by":"machine"},{"lesson":76,"detected":"2026-09-13","guard_landed":"2026-09-14","days_to_guard":1,"hold_state":"held","window_completes":"2026-10-12","window_stopped":"2026-10-12","broken_by_lesson":null,"caught_by":"person"},{"lesson":77,"detected":"2026-09-15","guard_landed":"2026-09-15","days_to_guard":0,"hold_state":"held","window_completes":"2026-10-13","window_stopped":"2026-10-13","broken_by_lesson":null,"caught_by":"person"},{"lesson":78,"detected":"2026-09-15","guard_landed":"2026-09-16","days_to_guard":1,"hold_state":"held","window_completes":"2026-10-14","window_stopped":"2026-10-14","broken_by_lesson":null,"caught_by":"machine"},{"lesson":81,"detected":"2026-09-16","guard_landed":"2026-09-21","days_to_guard":5,"hold_state":"broken","window_completes":"2026-10-19","window_stopped":"2026-09-22","broken_by_lesson":83,"caught_by":"person"},{"lesson":79,"detected":"2026-09-18","guard_landed":"2026-09-18","days_to_guard":0,"hold_state":"held","window_completes":"2026-10-16","window_stopped":"2026-10-16","broken_by_lesson":null,"caught_by":"person"},{"lesson":80,"detected":"2026-09-18","guard_landed":"2026-09-18","days_to_guard":0,"hold_state":"held","window_completes":"2026-10-16","window_stopped":"2026-10-16","broken_by_lesson":null,"caught_by":"person"},{"lesson":82,"detected":"2026-09-21","guard_landed":"2026-09-21","days_to_guard":0,"hold_state":"held","window_completes":"2026-10-19","window_stopped":"2026-10-19","broken_by_lesson":null,"caught_by":"person"},{"lesson":83,"detected":"2026-09-22","guard_landed":"2026-09-22","days_to_guard":0,"hold_state":"broken","window_completes":"2026-10-20","window_stopped":"2026-09-23","broken_by_lesson":90,"caught_by":"machine"},{"lesson":84,"detected":"2026-09-22","guard_landed":"2026-09-22","days_to_guard":0,"hold_state":"held","window_completes":"2026-10-20","window_stopped":"2026-10-20","broken_by_lesson":null,"caught_by":"unattributed"},{"lesson":85,"detected":"2026-09-22","guard_landed":"2026-09-22","days_to_guard":0,"hold_state":"held","window_completes":"2026-10-20","window_stopped":"2026-10-20","broken_by_lesson":null,"caught_by":"person"},{"lesson":86,"detected":"2026-09-23","guard_landed":"2026-09-23","days_to_guard":0,"hold_state":"held","window_completes":"2026-10-21","window_stopped":"2026-10-21","broken_by_lesson":null,"caught_by":"machine"},{"lesson":87,"detected":"2026-09-23","guard_landed":"2026-09-23","days_to_guard":0,"hold_state":"held","window_completes":"2026-10-21","window_stopped":"2026-10-21","broken_by_lesson":null,"caught_by":"person"},{"lesson":88,"detected":"2026-09-23","guard_landed":"2026-09-23","days_to_guard":0,"hold_state":"held","window_completes":"2026-10-21","window_stopped":"2026-10-21","broken_by_lesson":null,"caught_by":"unattributed"},{"lesson":89,"detected":"2026-09-23","guard_landed":"2026-09-23","days_to_guard":0,"hold_state":"held","window_completes":"2026-10-21","window_stopped":"2026-10-21","broken_by_lesson":null,"caught_by":"person"},{"lesson":90,"detected":"2026-09-23","guard_landed":"2026-09-24","days_to_guard":1,"hold_state":"held","window_completes":"2026-10-22","window_stopped":"2026-10-22","broken_by_lesson":null,"caught_by":"machine"},{"lesson":92,"detected":"2026-09-29","guard_landed":"2026-09-29","days_to_guard":0,"hold_state":"held","window_completes":"2026-10-27","window_stopped":"2026-10-27","broken_by_lesson":null,"caught_by":"unattributed"},{"lesson":93,"detected":"2026-09-30","guard_landed":"2026-10-01","days_to_guard":1,"hold_state":"held","window_completes":"2026-10-29","window_stopped":"2026-10-29","broken_by_lesson":null,"caught_by":"person"},{"lesson":94,"detected":"2026-10-02","guard_landed":"2026-10-03","days_to_guard":1,"hold_state":"broken","window_completes":"2026-10-31","window_stopped":"2026-10-03","broken_by_lesson":95,"caught_by":"machine"},{"lesson":95,"detected":"2026-10-03","guard_landed":"2026-10-03","days_to_guard":0,"hold_state":"held","window_completes":"2026-10-31","window_stopped":"2026-10-31","broken_by_lesson":null,"caught_by":"person"},{"lesson":96,"detected":"2026-10-06","guard_landed":"2026-10-06","days_to_guard":0,"hold_state":"held","window_completes":"2026-11-03","window_stopped":"2026-11-03","broken_by_lesson":null,"caught_by":"machine"},{"lesson":97,"detected":"2026-10-08","guard_landed":"2026-10-08","days_to_guard":0,"hold_state":"held","window_completes":"2026-11-05","window_stopped":"2026-11-05","broken_by_lesson":null,"caught_by":"person"},{"lesson":98,"detected":"2026-11-08","guard_landed":"2026-11-08","days_to_guard":0,"hold_state":"pending","window_completes":"2026-12-06","window_stopped":"2026-11-19","broken_by_lesson":null,"caught_by":"unattributed"}]}